We are getting more and more calls on the 1-800 LEMON LAW hotline from distressed drivers who are waiting for parts that are on back order.  They can’t understand why it takes so long to get their car fixed, and they are fed up with driving a loaner car for a month or more while they are awaiting the arrival of their part, normally from abroad.

So, why is this occurring and is there anything we can do about it under State Lemon Laws and/or the Federal Magnsuon Moss Warranty Act?

As we have previously reported, when the companies were trying to cut costs in the troubling economy, they closed down many of their factories.  The end result is that in many cases, they do not have the materials and manpower to ensure that parts are available in a quick and timely manner.  It’s the nature of the beast and no matter how hard they try to fix this situation, there is very little they can do.  If you have a problem that is not occurring in many vehicles, they are not prepared because they are not laying out funds to have parts just sit around.If it is regarding a problem that is occurring in a number of cars, they simply cannot fulfill the demand.

So, if your part is on back order and you find yourself without your car for a long period of time, what can be done?

The good news is most State Lemon Laws define a lemon as a car that is in the shop for an extended amount of time within a set period.  The Pennsylvania Lemon Law, for instance, defines a lemon as a car that is in the shop 30 or more days within the first 12 months or 12,000 miles.  The New Jersey Lemon Law defines a lemon as a car in the shop 20 or more days within the first 24 months or 24,000 miles.  To check out your state’s statute, click here.  In most cases, these days do NOT have to be consecutive, nor do they have to be for the same issue.Make sure sure that when your car is finally ready that you receive a repair invoice which clearly outlines the amount of time that car was in the shop.

Then contact us or another consumer attorney to look into your rights under the Lemon Law.  Under the Law, you may be entitled to a new car or complete repurchase. Even if the car is fixed you could be looking a significant monetary compensation to reflect the diminished value of the car (plus you would get to keep the vehicle.)  It’s really important that you know your rights and you fight for what is yours, especially since the the legal representation is free.

So what if you fall outside of the Lemon Law parameters, but your car is still sitting in the shop wasting a month or two away.  Please still get in touch with us.  We have successfully argued that this is a violation of the manufacturers warranty and we have been able to assist many consumers with monetary damages for breach of warranty as a result.

It is extremely rewarding when our lemon law attorneys are recognized by their peers, and for the seventh year in a row, Kimmel and Silverman founding attorneys Craig Thor Kimmel and Bob Silverman have been featured as Pennsylvania Super Lawyers in the Consumer Law division.

In addition, Managing Attorney Jacqueline Herritt has been named to the list for the fourth year in a row, and two of our associates, Amy Bennecoff and Richard Scholer, have been named Rising Stars in the Pennsylvania Legal Community. Kimmel and Silverman is proud to have more more consumer attorneys honored than any other firm in the State.

The findings are published in the June 2010 edition of Philadelphia Magazine. More than 34,000 attorneys were asked to vote for the most effective counsel they have personally observed in action. Kimmel and Silverman were recognized among the top 5% of all attorneys statewide for building Pennsylvania’s oldest and largest full-service lemon law firm, and assisting more than 55,000 distressed drivers across the Northeast with cost-free legal representation.

Kimmel & Silverman has an extensive history helping consumers and distressed drivers throughout the Keystone State, most notably as  the only lemon law firm in the state to work with the House of Representatives in expanding the Pennsylvania Lemon Law to include leased cars and tighter title provisions for used cars. The firm has also testified on bills to include additional protection for Pennsylvania consumers with motorcycles and recreational vehicles. In addition, when Chrysler was restructured and purchased by Fiat, attorneys Bob Silverman and Amy  Bennecoff worked with Chrysler counsel Jones Day and Fiat counsel Sullivan Cromwell to revise the Master Sales Agreement between the two companies to include specific language which protects past, present and future Chrysler, Dodge and Jeep drivers who suffer repetitive defects with their vehicles.

To read the entire press release, click here.  We extend our sincere thanks to the many lawyers throughout Philadelphia, Pittsburgh and all parts of the State who found our lawyers worthy of this honor.

Imagine buying one of those hot new Chevrolet Camaros.  You are cruising down the highway, enjoying every minute, when all of a sudden, the car won’t go into first gear or reverse.  The dealership identifies the problem and points to the clutch slave cylinder.  Apparently, there are a number of Camaros across the nation with the exact same problem. The good news is they know how to fix it; the bad news is you are going to be without your car for a little while….well more than a little while…..over a month….at least….maybe two months….but we will give you a loaner.

As a result of the troubling economy, closed factories and less dealerships, many consumers are hearing the term “National Back Order”  There is nothing you can do, other than sit back and wait the days, weeks, months until your part comes in and your car is fixed, right?

WRONG!  When you purchase a car with a manufacturers warranty, it is supposed to guarantee that your car is fixed efficiently and effectively and if it is not, you are entitled to recourse.  Under each of the State Lemon Laws we handle, you are entitled to file a claim if your car is out of service for an extended period of time, and that includes if a part is on back order.  In addition, these days do not have to be consecutive.

Under Pennsylvania Lemon Law, it’s 30 days within the first 12 months or 12,000 miles (whichever comes first).

Under New Jersey Lemon Law, it’s 20 days within the first 24 months or 24,000 miles (whichever comes first).

Under Delaware Lemon Law, it’s 30 days within the first 12 months of ownership.

Under Massachusetts Lemon Law, it’s 15 business days within the first year.

Under Maryland Lemon Law, it’s 30 days within the first 15 months of ownership.

Under Ohio Lemon Law, it’s 30 days within the first year of ownership.

Under New Hampshire Lemon Law, it’s 30 days within the manufacturers warranty period.

Under Connecticut Lemon Law, it’s 30 days within the first 24 months or 18,000 miles (whichever comes first).

Under New York Lemon Law, it’s 30 days wtihin the first 24 months or 18,000 miles (whichever comes first).

AND, EVEN IF THE CAR IS FIXED, the consumer still may be entitled to significant monetary compensation to reflect the diminished value of the car, PLUS they get to keep the vehicle.

For more information on what what you should you do if you are waiting for a part on national back order, drop us a line or call us at 1-800 LEMON LAW (1-800-536-6652).

Happy third anniversary lemon law blog buddies!  We can’t believe it’s been three years since we started our on-line community and we have appreciated the thousands of comments, blog topic ideas, suggestions and good wishes.  Here’s to the next year, where we will aim to provide even more comprehensive news and information on your lemon law and breach of warranty rights.

We decided that in our next series of blog entries, we will take a look at the lemon laws in each of the states we work in.  We start today with the Pennsylvania Lemon Law.  Pennsylvania is very near and dear to Kimmel and Silverman for two reasons. First, we started our practice in the State and have grown to become PA’s oldest and largest lemon law firm, handling over 30,000 claims statewide since our inception.  Second, Kimmel and Silverman worked with the Pennsylvania House of Representatives Consumer Affairs Committee in 2002 to actually add amendments to strengthen the PA Lemon Law, most notably to include leased vehicles.  This was a tremendous success for our Firm and the amendment has single handedly aided thousands since its inclusion.

The Pennsylvania Lemon Law applies to new cars purchased or leased in Pennsylvania and registered in PA, OR purchased in another state but registered in PA by the first owner immediately after purchase.  In order to qualify for remedy under the Pennsylvania Lemon Law, your vehicle must be used for personal use and must suffer its first non conformity (that’s a defect which affects the use, value or safety of the car) within the first 12 months or 12,000 miles, whichever comes first.  The problem must occur at least two more times under the Manufacturers warranty period OR the vehicle must be in the shop 30 days in the 12/12 period.  The 30 days do not have to be consecutive, nor do they have to be for the same problem.

Now, please note that although commercial vehicles, used cars, and motorcycles are NOT covered under the PA Lemon Law, there are other Laws we which may apply so call us at 1-800 LEMON LAW (1-800-536-6652) to find out about your rights and whether we can offer assistance. Remember, you never know unless you ask.

Next time…we will take a look at the Great Garden State…The New Jersey Lemon Law!

It’s time for another roundup of recent repurchases and refunds.  These blog entries are always our favorite to write.  Kimmel & Silverman is dedicated to being the oldest, largest and most helpful lemon law firm in the Northeast, successfully handling over 50,000 lemon law and breach of warranty claims since our inception at absolutely no cost to consumers.  The following are just a few of the cases resolved in the last 30 days:

• 2008 Nissan Altima -Complete Repurchase under New Jersey Lemon Law (resolved in 24 days)
• 2008 Mazda 3 -$6,500 cash under Pennsylvania Lemon Law (plus client kept their car)
• 2008 Suzuki Forenza -Complete Repurchase under Ohio Lemon Law (resolved in 23 days)
• 2005 Suzuki Forenza -$5,000 cash under Pennsylvania Lemon Law (plus client kept their car)
• 2008 GMC Yukon -Complete Repurchase under Ohio Lemon Law (resolved in 45 days)
• 2006 Kia Sedona -$4,500 cash under Magnuson Moss Warranty Act (plus client kept their car)
• Used 2008 Kia Sorento -$3,875 cash under Magnuson Moss Act (plus client kept their car)
• 2008 Suzuki Sx4 -Complete Repurchase under Pennsylvania Lemon Law (resolved in 41 days)
• 2006 Suzuki Grand Vitara -Complete Repurchase under Pennsylvania Lemon Law
• 2008 Subaru Impreza-$4,600 cash under Connecticut Lemon Law (plus client kept their car)
• 2009 Honda Accord-Complete Repurchase under New Jersey Lemon Law (resolved in 70 days)
• Used 2006 Mazda Tribute-$6,000 under Magnuson Moss Act (plus client kept their car)
• 2008 Mazda CX7 with 30,000 miles-$4,000 under New Jersey Lemon law (plus client kept car)
• 2008 GMC Siera -$5,000 cash under Pennsylvania Lemon Law (plus client kept their car)
• 2008 Lexus GS350 -Complete Repurchase under New Jersey Lemon Law
• Leased 2007 Jeep Wrangler with 27,000 miles – $5,000 under Magnsuon Moss Warranty Act
• 2008 Saturn Outlook – $7,000 cash under Pennsylvania Lemon Law (plus client kept their car)
• 2006 GMC Sierra – $5,000 cash under New York Lemon Law (plus client kept their car)
• 2009 Jeep Wrangler – Complete Repurchase under Pennsylvania Lemon Law (resolved in 60 days)
• 2007 BMW 3 series,first repair at 29,000 miles -$4,000 under Magnuson Moss Act (client kept car)
• Used 2003 Cadillac CTS with 64,000 miles -$3,000 under Magnuson Moss Act (plus client kept car)
• 2008 Lexus RX350 – Complete Repurchase under Massachusetts Lemon Law
• 2009 Mazda 6 – Complete Repurchase under New Jersey Lemon Law (resolved in 20 days)
• 2008 Audi A4 – Complete Repurchase under New Jersey Lemon Law (resolved in 3 months)
• Used 2007 Pontiac Solstice -$4,000 cash under Magnuson Moss Act (plus client kept car)
• 2008 GMC Arcadia – Complete Repurchase under Pennsylvania Lemon Law (resolved in 30 days)
• 2006 Chevrolet HHR with 26,000 miles- $4,500 under Maryland Lemon Law (plus client kept car)
• 2006 Volvo S60 – $6,500 under New Jersey Lemon Law (plus client kept car)
• Used 2006 Pontiac Torrent -$3,000 under Magnuson Moss Act (client kept car; resolved in 19 days)
• 2007 Chevrolet Tahoe, first defect at 20,000 miles -$5,500 under Magnuson Moss Act (client kept car)

If you feel you may have a potential lemon law or breach of warranty claim, contact us at 1-800 LEMON LAW (1-800-536-6652) or drop us a line.  We will be glad to review your situation and see if we can help.  With eleven Lemon Law attorneys, six full-service offices, three ASE-certified mechanics on staff, and a complete support team of experienced paralegals and administrators, no one can get you on the road to recovery quicker than Kimmel & Silverman. 

School may be out for Summer, but consumers should always be educated when it comes to their rights.  Many of the calls we receive at 1-800 LEMON LAW come specifically from distressed drivers who want to know if they fall under their State’s Lemon Law.  So, back by popular demand, it’s a Lemon Law 101 refresher course.  Of course, if you have any questions, do not hesitate to contact us either by e-mail or by calling 1-800 LEMON LAW (1-800-536-6652) and we will be glad to answer all of your questions. 

Now, without further ado, here is a quick rundown of the laws in the States we practice.  Click on the State for more information.  For information on other state, please visit Lemon Law America.

Pennsylvania Lemon Law :  First problem must occur in first 12 months or 12,000 miles whichever comes first.  The problem must occur three or more times under warranty OR the car is in the shop 30 or more days within the first year, and those days do not have to be consecutive. Car must be purchased (or leased) and registered in PA.  Motorcycles are not covered under PA Lemon Law  (but they are covered under the Federal Magnuson Moss Warranty Act so we can still help!)–Kimmel & Silverman was directly responsible for getting leased cars included under the PA Lemon Law.

New Jersey Lemon Law :  Second most effective Lemon Law in the Nation! First problem must occur in first 24 months or 18,000 miles which ever comes first. Problem must occur three or more times under warranty OR the car is in the shop for 20 days in the first 24 months/18,000 miles and they do not have to be consecutive. Motorcycles are covered under NJ Lemon Law. Vehicle can be purchased, leased or registered in New Jersey.

Delaware Lemon Law : First problem must occur in the first year of ownership.  Problem must occur four or more times under warranty OR the car is in the shop 30 or more BUSINESS days in the first year. Vehicle can be purchased, leased or registered in Delaware. Motorcycles are not covered under DE Lemon Law  (but they are covered under the Federal Magnuson Moss Warranty Act so we can still help!)

Maryland Lemon Law : First problem must occur in the first 15 months or 15,000 miles of ownership. Problem must occur four or more times under warranty OR the car is in the shop 30 or more days in the first 15 months. Vehicle must be purchased or leased in Maryland. Motorcycles are covered.  Commercial trucks under one ton are also covered.

Massachusetts Lemon Law : First problem must occur in the first year or 15,000 miles whichever comes first. Problem must occur three or more times under warranty OR the car is in the shop 15 BUSINESS days in the first year. Motorcycles are not covered under MA Lemon Law  (but they are covered under the Federal Magnuson Moss Warranty Act so we can still help!)

Ohio Lemon Law : First problem must occur in the first year or 18,000 miles, whichever comes first. Problem must occur three or more times under warranty OR eight problems must occur OR in the shop 30 or more days in the first year. Motorcycles are covered under the OH Lemon Law.

Connecticut Lemon Law : First problem must occur within the first 24 months or 18,000 miles, whichever comes first, and can continue 4x throughout the original and/or extended manufacturers warranty period. Connecticut’s Lemon Law also applies to vehicles that are in the shop for repair thirty (30) or more calendar days during the first 18,000 miles or 24 months (whichever comes first) and these days do not have to be consecutive. Motorcycles are covered.

New York Lemon Law :  First problem must first occur within the first 24 months or 18,000 miles, whichever comes first and happen 4 times. The New York Lemon Law also applies to vehicles that are in the shop for repair thirty (30) or more calendar days during the first year. Motorcycles are covered.

New Hampshire Lemon Law : Vehicles purchased or leased  in NH with a gross weight of under 9000 pounds, that suffer a problem that cannot be repaired after three attempts by an authorized manufacturer’s dealership. This nonconformity must occur within the warranty period. The New Hampshire Lemon Law also applies to vehicles that are in the shop for repair thirty (30) or more business days during the express warranty period.  Motorcycles are covered.

Under State Lemon Laws, you could be entitled to one of the following three possible remedies:
1. First  remedy can be a new vehicle – an MSRP TO MSRP swap.  MSRP stands for manufacturers suggested retail price. You will receive a credit for the MSRP/sticker price of your car which can be applied to the MSRP of any new car within the manufacturer.  Ideally, if you are interested in the same car, there should be little or no upgrade cost.   Essentially, this is a trade WITHOUT depreciation.  You will be put into a new vehicle with the same amount of equity as your old vehicle.

2. A full refund of your money, including finance charges, taxes, tags, down payment trade in value minus a small mileage offset (When it comes to offsets, each state is different. You give back the car, it is branded a lemon and you are done. )

3. The third possible remedy is monetary compensation to reflect the diminished value of the car.  Part of what you pay for when purchasing a car is a manufacturers warranty and that is to ensure that the problems you fix are fixed efficiently and effectively and if they are not after a certain number of times, your warranty has been breached.  If you receive compensation, you will get to keep the car, the car is NOT branded in any way, shape or form, your warranty remains completely in effect and you do not need to disclose that you received this money at time of trade or sale.  FURTHERMORE, EVEN IF YOUR CAR IS FIXED, YOU COULD STILL BE ENTITLED TO THIS MONEY.

If a person does not fall under the Lemon law, that does not mean we can’t help them.  As long as they have been in under manufacturers warranty three times for the same problem or four times for the same problem in Maryland, we can file a claim under the Magnuson Moss Warranty Act.  This applies to cars that were either purchased used or the first problem fell outside the parameters of the State Lemon Law.

Bottom line:  If you have a manufacturers warranty and have been in the shop repeated times for the same problem, chances are we can help.  Please feel free to get in touch with us any time to discuss how we can provide free legal representaiton in your particular situation.

Late last month, we worked on an investigative report with WTAE TV reporter Paul Van Osdel, uncovering which cars provides the most headaches for drivers throughout the Keystone State. Paul obtained a list from PENNDot (Pennsylvania Department of Transportation) and according to their records, from 2003-2008, Chevrolet led the list of lemons in Pennsylvania. Their list is as follows:

Chevrolet (their story featured 1-800 LEMON LAW client Sarah Griffith of Monroeville, who received a complete buyback after suffering problems with her Trailblazer)

Ford
Dodge
Nissan
Suzuki
Jeep
Hyundai
Cadillac
Volkswagen
GMC

We find this list to be rather incomplete, as it only covers vehicles that were purchased back from the manufacturer and officially titled as lemons. The list does not include vehicles where consumers received thousands of dollar in monetary damages and were able to keep their cars.

Being that we are the oldest and largest lemon law firm in Western Pennsylvania, Paul asked us to compile a list of the cars we see the most in our Pittsburgh caseload. Although he didn’t have time for the information in the story, we thought it would be interesting to give our top 10:
Chevrolet Cobalt
Chevrolet Impala
Chevrolet Silverado
Chevrolet Malibu
Jeep Grand Cherokee
Jeep Liberty
Chevrolet Equinox
Kia Sedona
Pontiac G6
Saturn VUE
Jeep Commander
Jeep Wrangler

and of course, to view the cars that receive the most complaints nationally per sales, check out the 2009 Car Complaint Index.

When Bob Silverman & Craig Kimmel formed Kimmel & Silverman eighteen years ago, they had one goal in mind–to equal the playing field between the consumer and the billion-dollar automotive manufacturer, using State & Federal Laws that many consumers were not aware of.  Best of all, the legal help under these laws is completely FREE to the consumer. 

For the life of us, we cannot understand why consumers still insist on trying to do this by themselves, when you can have access to an experienced attorney who has worked on thousands of lemon law and breach of warranty claims (not only that, but we have three ASE-certified mechanics on staff to inspect our clients’ vehicles and research their issues.)  The other day, a gentleman called with a real problem–he was two years into a four-year lease and he was experiencing many problems with his power-train.  Being that he thought he had a “slam dunk” case, he decided to represent himself through the NJ Lemon Law unit.  He couldn’t get a mechanic to testify on his behalf. The manufacturer hired attorneys to oppose his claim.  He ended being offered a very minimal settlement which only covered a few lease payments.  He now has decided to buy himself out of his lease, which means he is going to take a huge financial hit.  This is all because he thought he could handle this on his own.  We have seen many other claims where the consumer was promised a new car, only it turned out to be a trade and the consumer found themselves stuck in a terrible situation.  If you are not a doctor, can you diagnose someone with a chest pain? If you are not a contractor, can you build a house and ensure it’s going to last the test of time?  The legal help is free, the participation is minimal.  You can keep driving your car throughout the entire process….if you don’t take advantage of what the Law provides, then you are partly to blame for whatever happens.

We know that It sounds too good to be true, but we can assure you it is for real. You can read the many consumer stories we have in our on-line newsroom, or just take a look at some of our recent victories from the last quarter. The following are some of the repurchases we have successfully obtained in the last four months.  These clients received all taxes, tags, finance charges, monthly payments and value on their trade-ins, minus a very small mileage offset normally based on the mileage when they first brought the car to the authorized manufacturers dealership for service.  And how much did they pay for legal fees?  if you answered “nothing,” you get a gold star!

• 2007 Nissan Quest — repurchase under MA Lemon Law
• 2008 Nissan XTerra — repurchase under PA Lemon Law
• 2007 Nissan Quest — repurchase under NJ Lemon Law
• 2005 Nissan Murano — repurchase under PA Lemon Law (client had 26,800 miles when he called us.)
• 2005 Nissan Altima — repurchase under PA Lemon Law (client had 30,126 miles when he called us.)
• 2007 Chevrolet Silverado — Two repurchases in last four months under PA Lemon Law
• 2008 Chevrolet Colorado — repurchase under PA Lemon Law
• 2008 Chevrolet HHR — repurchase under NJ Lemon Law (settled in 28 days)
• 2007 Chevrolet Trailblazer — repurchase under PA Lemon Law (settled in 19 days)
• 2008 Chevrolet Cobalt — repurchase under NJ Lemon Law
• 2007 GMC Sierra — repurchase under NJ Lemon Law
• 2007 GMC Yukon — repurchase under PA Lemon Law (settled in 20 days)
• 2008 GMC Arcadia — repurchase under NJ Lemon Law (settled in 27 days)
• 2007 GMC Arcadia — repurchase under DE Lemon Law
• 2008 GMC Envoy — repurchase under OH Lemon Law (settled in 19 days)
• 2008 GMC Yukon — repurchase under OH Lemon Law
• 2006 Cadillac CTS — repurchase under PA Lemon Law
• 2007 Cadillac SRX — repurchase under MA Lemon Law
• 2006 Cadillac XLRV — repurchase under MA Lemon Law
• 2008 Cadillac CTS — repurchase under NJ Lemon Law
• 2008 Saturn Vue — repurchase under PA Lemon Law (settled in 12 days)
• 2008 Saturn ION — repurchase under PA Lemon Law
• 2007 Saturn ION — repurchase under PA Lemon Law
• 2008 Hummer H3 — repurchase under NJ Lemon Law
• 2006 Suzuki Forenza — repurchase under VT Lemon Law
• 2008 Audi A4 — repurchase under NH Lemon Law
• 2006 Hyundai Elantra — repurchase under PA Lemon Law
• 2007 Dodge Ram — Two repurchases under PA Lemon Law
• 2007 Dodge Ram — Two repurchases under VT Lemon Law
• 2008 Dodge Ram – repurchase under PA Lemon Law
• 2007 Dodge Caliber — repurchase under PA Lemon Law
• 2008 Dodge Caliber –repurchase under PA Lemon Law
• 2008 Dodge Grand Caravan — repurchase under NJ Lemon Law
• 2008 Chrysler Sebring Convertible — repurchase under OH Lemon Law
• 2008 Chrysler Sebring Convertible — repurchase under PA Lemon Law
• 2007 Chrysler Town & Country — repurchase under PA Lemon Law
• 2008 Jeep Patriot — repurchase under PA Lemon Law
• 2006 Jeep Wrangler — repurchase under OH Lemon Law
• 2007 Jeep Commander — repurchase under OH Lemon Law
• 2007 Jeep Wrangler — repurchase under NJ Lemon Law
• 2006 Toyota Scion — repurchase under PA Lemon Law
• 2007 Toyota Solara –repurchase under PA Lemon Law
• 2008 Toyota Corolla — repurchase under PA Lemon Law
• 2008 Lexus LS460 — repurchase under NJ Lemon Law
• 2007 Lexus ES350 –repurchase under PA Lemon Law
• 2006 Lexus LX470 — repurchase under NJ Lemon Law
• 2007 Lexus GS300 — repurchase under PA Lemon Law
• 2008 Lexus GS400 — repurchase under OH Lemon Law
• 2005 Ford Mustang — repurchase under PA Lemon Law

Now, remember this is a legal process, so we can’t guarantee that you will receive a repurchase if you open a claim with us, but it could be possible.

Under the Laws we work with, a repurchase is the maximum remedy a consumer can receive.  Repurchases are reserved where the consumer has suffered a significant non-conformity which has affected the use, value and safety of the vehicle, and the problem has reoccurred repeatedly.  Another possible remedy under the Lemon Law is a new car. This known as an MSRP to MSRP swap, which is essentially a trade without the depreciation you would normally suffer.  As you know, the minute you drive a car off the lot, the value of the car depreciates significantly.  If you receive a swap, we take the MSRP from the sticker price of your car and apply it to the MSRP of a brand new car.  So, essentially you are getting a brand new car with the same features, and you have the same amount of equity in the new car as you did in the old car. The depreciation you would normally deal with does not apply.

There is also a third remedy under the State Lemon Laws and most commonly under the Federal Magnuson Moss Warranty Act–significant monetary compensation to reflect the diminished value of the vehicle for the problems you have incurred. This could apply if it is fixed after three repairs; if the problem is not threatening the overall use, value, or safety f the vehicle (i.e. radio);  it falls outside the lemon law mileage provisions; or if you purchased the car used but it still has a manufacturers warranty.  If you receive money, it is non-taxable and YOU GET TO KEEP YOUR CAR and your car is not branded in any way, shape or form.  Plus, your warranty remains completely in effect, so the manufacturer  is  still obligated to fix the car if problems persist, and you do not need to disclose that you received this money at time of trade or sale.  You may do whatever you want with the money.  You may have previously read in our blog about the Volvo SUV owner who received $7,000 after he heard Communications Director Michael Sacks on the radio. Here are some other folks who received monetary awards in the last four months(All of these folks kept their vehicles and had their attorney fees paid sepearately by the manufacturer):

• 2008 Volvo C70 — problems with convertible top, fixed after 4th attempt. Client received $10,000.
• 2008 Ford Ranger — client received $5,000.
• 2007 Ford Expedition — client received $6,000.
• 2005 Ford F350 — client received $7,000.
• 2007 Ford Expedition – client received $4,000.
• 2008 Toyota Rav 4 — client received $5,500.
• 2009 Dodge Journey purchased in another state but registered in PA — client received $6,750.
• 2006 Dodge Caravan –client received $5,250.
• 2007 Jeep Liberty — client received $5,000.
• 2006 Chrysler Town & Country with 32,000 miles — client received $3,250.
• 2006 Subaru Forrester with 61,000 miles — client received $4,000 (settled in 60 days).
• 2008 Land Rover LR 3 with 25,000 miles — client received $4,250.
• 2008 Saab 9-7 with 37,000 miles — client received $5,500.
• 2005 Saab 9-3 with 40,000 miles and the lease almost completed — client received $3,000.
• 2005 Mazda 3 with 50,536 miles — client received $4,000.
• 2006 Mazda 6 purchased used — client received $4,000.
• 2006 Mazda MPV — client received $4,500 (settled in 30 days).
• 2007 Mazda CX9 –client received $5,000 (settled in 45 days).
• 2006 Honda Civic with 32,700 miles, problems fell outside of lemon law — client received $3,500.
• 2005 Chevrolet Tahoe with problem starting at 29,000 miles and lease up – client received $4,000.
• 2005 Chevrolet Impala with problem starting at 25,000 miles — client received $3,000.
• 2004 BMW 7-series certified pre-owned with 56,600 miles — client received $2,500.
• 2004 BMW 5-series with problem starting at 52,000 miles & extended wty – client received $3,000.

And this is just a sampling of the work we have done in the last four months.  Think you have a lemon?    E-mail us you question or call us at 1-800 LEMON LAW (1-800-536-6652) and we will be happy to go over your situation and whether we can help.

A law that actually helps consumers AND provides free legal help?  It seems too good to be true, but the State and Federal Laws do provide equal footing between you and the billion-dollar automobile manufacturer.  This provides you the opportunity to have a Lemon Law Attorney who knows and understands the Laws, who has significant experience fighting these types of claims, and who has immediate access to the decision makers and attorneys who represent the manufacturer.  This attorney and their staff can also offer additional support throughout a difficult time, providing answers to your questions and helping you deal with obstacles you are facing (i.e. a mechanic not diagnosing a problem properly or at all, a service manager refusing to give you paperwork, job tickets being left open so it seems like you are in the shop less than you are.)

The most common question we receive at 1-800 LEMON LAW is “How do I know my car is a lemon?” So, today on the lemon law blog, we thought we would provide a rundown of the lemon laws in each of the States we work in….But first, answers to five of the most frequently asked questions:

First, YOU CAN NOT RETURN A CAR IN THE FIRST 72 HOURS. This is a common misconception from the days of door-to-door sales, when folks would ring your doorbell and sell you a vacuum or a set of encyclopedias. Once you sign on the dotted line, the car is yours.  Period. Make sure that the right price is listed on the contract, make sure you can afford the car, make sure it’s the finance rate you agreed to and for goodness sake, NEVER EVER EVER sign a blank contract!

Second, THE DEFENDANT IS NOT THE DEALER.  Yes, we know the dealer is lovely and we know you don’t want to get them in any trouble.  But, they don’t make the car.  They are the middle man and they have nothing to do with filing a lemon law claim. In fact, when filing a claim, we ask clients not to discuss the case with the service manager or threaten the dealer that you are going to file a suit.  We do not want you to create a hostile relationship between you and the dealer.  Also, we are NOT a fan of last chance letters. So, you give the dealer a last chance to fix it…and they don’t.  Then what?  If you don’t have a lawyer to enforce the letter, you are stuck in a catch-22.  Again, the law offers FREE help–Take advantage of it!

Third, EVEN IF YOU FALL OUTSIDE OF THE LEMON LAW, WE STILL MAY BE ABLE TO HELP YOU. Do not be discouraged if you have a used car or a motorcycle or ATV in a state that does not cover them. If your problems are covered under an original or extended manufacturers warranty, you could be entitled to MONETARY COMPENSATION, plus you get to keep your vehicle, your warranty remains in full effect, and the vehicle is NOT branded in any way.

Fourth, EVEN IF YOUR CAR IS FIXED AFTER THE THIRD, FOURTH, OR FIFTH REPAIR, you could still be entitled to compensation.  The fact is that every car comes with a manufacturers warranty and that is to ensure that problems are fixed efficiently and effectively and they have not been.  So, we feel you are entitled to money back, significant money, to reflect the diminished value of the car as a result of your problems. Again, if you receive money, the car is NOT branded and the warranty is fully in effect. Plus, the money is non-taxable.

Fifth, THERE ARE THREE POSSIBLE REMEDIES UNDER THE LAWS WE WORK WITH.  Keep in mind this is a legal process, so there are no guarantees, but here is what we are looking at.  Maximum remedy is a full buyback, including taxes, tags, finance charges, etc minus a small mileage offset as prescribed your state.  You return your car to the dealer and it is branded a lemon.  Second, an MSRP to MSRP swap–MSRP stands for manufacturers suggested retail price–basically, you are getting behind the wheel of a brand new car, with same amount of equity as your old car.  It’s trade without depreciation.  Third, if we can’t get a buyback or a swap, we aim to get you as much money as possible in compensation to reflect the diminished value as a result of the problem incurred. Plus, as mentioned before, you get to keep the car.

OK–on that note, here’s a quick rundown of the laws in our states.  For other states, click here.  Have questions?  E-mail us or call 1-800 LEMON LAW (1-800-536-6652).  Here we go:

Pennsylvania Lemon Law :  First problem must occur in first 12 months or 12,000 miles whichever comes first.  Problem must occur three or more times under warranty OR the car is in the shop 30 or more days within the first year, and those days do not have to be consecutive. Car must be purchased (or leased) and registered in PA.  Motorcycles are not covered under PA Lemon Law  (but they are covered under the Federal Magnuson Moss Warranty Act so we can still help!)–Kimmel & Silverman was directly responsible for getting leased cars included under the PA Lemon Law.

New Jersey Lemon Law :  Second most effective Lemon Law in the Nation! First problem must occur in first 24 months or 18,000 miles which ever comes first. Problem must occur three or more times under warranty OR the car is in the shop for 20 days in the first 24 months and they do not have to be consecutive. Motorcycles are covered under NJ Lemon Law. Vehicle can be purchased, leased or registered in New Jersey.

Delaware Lemon Law : First problem must occur in the first year of ownership.  Problem must occur four or more times under warranty OR the car is in the shop 30 or more BUSINESS days in the first year. Vehicle can be purchased, leased or registered in Delaware. Motorcycles are not covered under DE Lemon Law  (but they are covered under the Federal Magnuson Moss Warranty Act so we can still help!)

Massachusetts Lemon Law: First problem must occur in the first year or 15,000 miles whichever comes first. Problem must occur three or more times under warranty OR the car is in the shop 15 BUSINESS days in the first year. Motorcycles are not covered under MA Lemon Law  (but they are covered under the Federal Magnuson Moss Warranty Act so we can still help!)

Ohio Lemon Law : First problem must occur in the first year or 18,000 miles, whichever comes first. Problem must occur three or more times under warranty OR eight problems must occur OR in the shop 30 or more days in the first year. Motorcycles are covered under the OH Lemon Law.

Vermont Lemon Law : First problem must occur three times under warranty period OR in the shop 30 days. Vehciles may be purchased or registered in Vermont.  Motorcycles are not covered under VT Lemon Law  (but they are covered under the Federal Magnuson Moss Warranty Act so we can still help!)

Washington DC Lemon Law : First problem must occur three or more times in the first 2 years or 18,000 miles. Problem must occur 4 or more times under warranty OR be in the shop 30 days in the first two years. Motorcycles are not covered under DC Lemon Law  (but they are covered under the Federal Magnuson Moss Warranty Act so we can still help!)

For more information on your rights, visit lemon law. com or one of our favorite National lemon law websites, Lemon Law America.

Lemon Law Attorneys Bob Silverman and Jacqueline Herritt were featured on WYOU TV Interactive News last night, discussing consumers rights under the Pennsylvania Lemon Law and the Federal Magnuson Moss Warranty Act.  The program also offered viewers the chance to call in and discuss their lemon horror stories with Kimmel and Silverman staff members. You can watch the video here.

In the meantime, here is a quick refresher on the PA Lemon Law:

• The first problem must occur in the first 12 months or 12,000 miles, whichever comes first. (If the problem occurs after the first 12 months, the consumer would have a claim under Federal Law.)
• The problem must significantly affect the use, value or safety of the vehicle.
• The problem must occur three times (or more) under the manufacturers warranty.
• OR the car should be in the shop 30 or more days in the first year and they don’t need to be consecutive.
• Maximum remedy under the PA Lemon Law is a new car (MSRP to MSRP swap), or a complete buyback of the car, including finance charges, taxes and tags, minus a small mileage offset based on the mileage when the problem was first reported. 
• A consumer could also receive monetary damages to reflect the diminished value of the car as a result of the problems suffered, plus they get to keep their car.  The car’s warranty remains in effect; the consumer does not need to disclose that they received money at the time of trade or sale; and the car is NOT branded a lemon on carfax or autocheck.
• Motorcycles and used cars are not covered, however if the vehicles are in the shop three or more times under warranty for the same problem, they could qualify for monetary recourse under the Federal Law. 
• Legal help is completely cost-free under both the State and Federal Laws.  If the consumer prevails, the manufacturer must pay all attorney fees and legal costs ON TOP OF what the consumer receives. If a lemon law firm does take your case, they should not charge you if you do not prevail.  Therefore, fighting for your rights under the Lemon Law is cost-free and risk-free.

If you have any additional questions regarding the Pennsylvania Lemon Law, click here.  To read about Lemon Laws in other states, click here.

This morning, while taping a segment for the CW talk show “Speak Up,” we met up with one of our former clients, John Bryant.  John, an accomplished attorney himself, had endured several significant problems with his Cadillac. The battery kept dying, again and again, and he found himself back at the dealer on five different occasions.  He thought that General Motors would certainly do the right thing and exchange his car with a new one under the Pennsylvania Lemon Law.  When they refused, he upped the ante and told the dealer he would pay them $10,000 and turn in his car in exchange for a new car and he was still getting the run-around.  It was around that time that his daughter got involved.  She had heard about Kimmel & Silverman and she looked up lemon law.com on-line.  Once John contacted us, we started representation and shortly after, John received an MSRP to MSRP swap, exchanging his 2003 Cadillac for a 2008 Cadillac.  He paid NO attorney fees (as you know, if we can help, it is completely free) and only paid $2,400 in mileage and upgrade offset, MUCH LESS than what he offered the dealer.   Needless to say, he was thrilled.

So, what’s the moral of the story?  Dealers can only do so much to help the consumer.  When dealing with a lemon law or breach of warranty issue, the defendant is NOT the dealer; it is the manufacturer. Many a dealer has whispered “1-800-LEMON-LAW’ to their customers over the years.  They do this because they know they have no control, and really want to help.  If you find yourself in a similar situation, don’t bend the dealer’s ear, hoping that he will come to your rescue.  Instead, research your lemon law and breach of warranty rights, make sure you keep all of your repair invoices, and look into hiring a lemon law attorney.  It is cost-free and risk-free.

For those in the Delaware Valley, “Speak Up” will air this Sunday morning at 8am on CW57. In addition to John, the program will feature lemon law attorney Amy Bennecoff and Director of Communications & Automotive Consumer Advocate Michael Sacks.

While Pennsylvania has always had a lemon law for new cars, Philadelphia has now instituted a lemon law for used cars sold in the city. Mayor Nutter has signed Philadelphia’s first Used Car Lemon Law Bill, sponsored by Councilman Darrell L. Clarke.  The Used Car Lemon Law ensures that purchasers of used cars in Philadelphia have the opportunity to have the car inspected by a licensed mechanic with 72 hours of purchase.  If a major structural defect is found, the consumer has the right to have to return the car for repair or a full refund.

Here are the details:

**A purchaser of a used car may return their vehicle within 72 hours after purchase if it is unable to pass safety or emissions inspections or found by a certified inspection mechanic to have an undisclosed major structural defect (The mechanic MUST put his findings in writing.)

**Upon return of the car, the dealer has 10 days to either fix the car, entirely at their own expense, or refund the consumer’s money.

**Dealer must also provide a copy of any written warranty to the purchaser within 15 days of payment for the warranty, and shall perform all repairs covered under the warranty promptly. At the time of purchase, the delaer MUST disclose in lareg capital letters whether the warranty is provided by the dealer, the manufacturer or a third-party warranty.

**If you purchased a used car and feel the dealer is not upholding their responsibilities, contact the Philadelphia Office of Consumer Affairs at 215-686-7598. They will take complaints and determine their merit.  Repeat offenders face possible suspension or revocation of their Automotbile Sales License and/or Business Privilege License.

Kudos to Mayor Nutter, Councilman Clark and Lance Haver at the Consumer Affairs Office for making this happen.

At 1-800-LEMON LAW, we receive countless calls from folks who purchased a used car and ended up being taken for a ride. Sometimes the car has a salvage title, or it will not pass inspection, or it just falls apart. Many times, these distressed drivers have little or no protection under the State and Federal Laws we work with. Now, Mayor Nutter’s consumer advocate Lance Haver is working hard to change that in Philadelphia.

This past Monday, The Philadelphia City Council has approved a lemon law bill for used cars, and if that bill becomes law, drivers will have 72 hours to get their car checked out by a mechanic following the purchase. If the car is not drivable, the dealer will either have to fix the problem or allow the consumer to return the car for a full refund.

This is a bill whose time has come, according to Kimmel & Silverman Founding Attorney Craig Thor Kimmel. “In Philadelphia, used car sales occur with greater frequency than in less populated areas for the simple fact that insurance on a used car in the city is cheaper than insurance on a new car. Often people who buy used must rely entirely on what they are told from their salesperson, as there is little or no warranty remaining. In the case of new cars, repairs are covered under warranty for free but sadly, that is not often the case for used cars. Avoiding an unreliable car and its high repair bills is critical. This type of consumer protection would certainly be welcomed.”

As you know, the Pennsylvania Lemon Law currently does not apply to used cars. However, if you are under a manufacturer’s warranty and you have been back three or more times, you could be entitled to monetary damages under a Federal law known as the Magnuson Moss Warranty Act. Like the Lemon Law, representation under this Law is completely cost-free. For more information, call us at 1-800 LEMON LAW or visit www.lemonlaw.com.

Lemon Lawyer Craig Thor Kimmel was featured in this Fox Undercover story on Ford F-Trucks catching fire as a result of unsuccessful cruise control recall that wasn’t performed on many vehicles. If this has happened to you, please contact Michael Sacks, Kimmel and Silverman’s Client Services Director, at 800-536-6652 ext. 131 or via e-mail at msacks@lemonlaw.com.

Lemon Aid

Driving a clunker?  There is help.

By Dan Sokil (staff writer)

Norristown Reporter

February 9, 2008

Maybe you’ve heard a catchy tune, or seen a commercial on TV about it.  But what exactly are you supposed to do if you find yourself driving a “lemon”? Roy “Duke” Milner of Lansdale knows first-hand the problem that can occur. He was having problems with a 2005 Cadillac XLR. “I purchased this Cadillac, new, and everything was fine with it for not quite a year,” said Milner.  “Then all of a sudden the trunk was leaking.”

“I returned it to the dealer at least five times, and it was in the shop for about 45 days total, and they just didn’t seem to be able to fix it,” Milner said.

After explaining his situation to Kimmel & Silverman, who filed a Lemon Law case against the manufacturer, Cadillac quickly reached a settlement with the law firm and Milner was able to purchase a new car.

“It took two weeks at most; I was very satisfied,” said Milner.  “I was somewhat apprehensive about this, and didn’t think it would get resolved, but was very pleased that it did.”

Pennsylvania’s Lemon Law, according to Kimmel & Silverman’s website LemonLaw.com, “applies to new cars that suffer a nonconformity; a defect or condition, which substantially impairs the use, value or safety; that cannot be repaired after three attempts by an authorized manufacturer’s dealership.”

However, several requirements must be met first.  The defect must have occurred within one year or 12,000 miles of purchasing the car, or the terms of the manufacturer’s warranty, whichever comes first. The defect must substantially impair the use, market value, or safety of the car.  It also cannot be the result of an accident, abuse, neglect or alteration of the car by someone other than the authorized dealer.

The manufacturer must also attempt three times to repair the defect, or the car must be out of service for a total of 30 calendar days, before a Lemon Law case may be brought. 

However, according to attorney Bob Silverman of Kimmel & Silverman (which runs the website LemonLaw.com), contacting the manufacturer yourself is not as successful as it once was. “Most manufacturers are cutting so many employees these days,” said Silverman, “that we’re hearing from our customers that they’re merely being patronized, and that just makes things worse.

Since Lemon Law firms like Kimmel & Silverman have direct access to manufacturer’s legal departments, he added, cases represented by firms that specialize in Lemon Law cases are often resolved more quickly. That proved to be the case for Mallory Durrick of North Wales, who purchased new Nissan Versa in May 2007.  The auto quickly developed a water leak and then a mold problem on the front passenger floor.

“They determined first that there was a leak in the seal of the windshield,” said Durrick, “and fixed it, said they were 100 percent satisfied with the repair.” About a month later, on the way to a regular oil change, Durrick noticed the problem had returned.

“I couldn’t believe it.  They kept my car for 32 days,” Durrick said, ultimately finding a leak in an air conditioning line.

“When they ripped up the seats and carpeting, the seats of the car were covered in green and black mold,” said Durrick.

After third-party testing by NAL East Environmental Services of Feasterville confirmed the high levels of mold in her vehicle, Durrick tried to contact the manufacturer through the dealership where she purchased the car.

“Nissan was refusing to help me, but Montgomeryville (where she purchased the car) was great,” said Durrick, who filed a Lemon Law case with Kimmel & Silverman.

They reached an agreement with Nissan to buy back Durrick’s car, and she recently returned it.

“I didn’t find it to be difficult at all,” she said.  “Since the Lemon Law protects the consumer, all of the legal costs were paid by the manufacturer.”

That cost protection is the key to protecting consumers, said Silverman. “The reason why (Pennsylvania) decided to make litigation free to consumers,” Silverman said, “is because they realize how important it is to level the playing field, between these big manufacturers and consumers.”

Looking for a quick, informative TV feature outlining your rights under the Lemon Law?  Check out a great piece by Fox Philadelphia consumer reporter Michelle Williams by clicking here!

Looking for a fun way to kick in Fall? Join Kimmel & Silverman for the City of Ambler’s OctoberFest Sunday, September 30 from Noon-5pm on Butler Avenue in Ambler, PA. Food, shopping, and entertainment are all on the agenda. Be sure to stop by our information station, right in front of the Kimmel & Silverman building on 30 E. Butler Avenue for useful lemon law reading materials, lemon yellow frisbees and other fun giveaways. We will also be on hand to answer your questions regarding your rights under the PA Lemon Law and Federal Breach of Warranty Laws. Hope to see you there!

Ever wonder what happens to lemon cars once they are bought back by the manufacturer? Last Sunday, The New York Times printed an interesting story which should shed some light on this mystery.

ManyPennsylvania consumers are unaware that in 2002, K&S Attorney Craig Thor Kimmel worked with the Pennsyvlania House of Representatives’ Consumer Affairs Committee to ammend the lemon law to include tighter title provisions for used cars.  Here’s the press release from our news room:

PA LEMON LAW TAKES EFFECT TODAY

New Pennsylvania Lemon Law Will Require Dealers, Lessors, and Transferors To Disclose If Used Car Has Lemon History

Harrisburg, PA (December 2,2002) – A new change to the Pennsylvania Lemon Law to help used car consumers takes place today. House Bill 767, a measure to protect used car buyers from purchasing lemon buybacks without full disclosure, was signed by Governor Mark Schweiker in October and goes into effect today. The change marks the second major amendment to the Pennsylvania Lemon Law Statute in the past year; the first being the expansion of the Law to include leased cars. Pennsylvania is the first state to take this type of action.

Until now, if a car was bought back by the manufacturer under the Pennsylvania Lemon Law, the manufacturer must fix the car, and place a sticker on the window notifying the next purchaser of its history. The manufacturer must also provide a 12 month, 12,000 mile warranty for the vehicle at no charge. Representative John R. Evans (R-District 5, Erie and Crawford Counties), the prime sponsor of HB 767, says the Law didn’t do enough to ensure that consumers would actually receive the notice. “What we found as that some dealers would purchase the car from the manufacturer and strip the disclosure and resell the car to an unsuspecting customer.”

With the provisions of HB 767 added, the PA Lemon Law now requires all dealers and other classified sellers, to disclose the “lemon” history of a used car and also to obtain a signature from the buyer or lessee before the sale/lease. “Requiring a written disclosure from each purchaser, lessee and transferee for the life of the vehicle, ensures that all parties know exactly what they are doing before the sale is finalized.” says Evans. Lemon Law Attorney and Automobile Consumer Advocate Craig Thor Kimmel, a legal consultant to the House Consumer Affairs Committee, says the change will provide immediate benefits to used car purchasers. “The amendment clearly spells out the responsibilities of anyone selling a lemon buy-back in Pennsylvania,” says Kimmel, adding, “With used cars purchases on the upswing, the law did not adequately protect consumers. Now the consumer will be told what they are buying before the sale, and dealers and other sellers are held accountable if they don’t do what they are required to.”

If a manufacturer or dealer fails to comply with the disclosure requirements, and/or the consumer is not notified in the way specified, the dealer or seller faces stiff civil penalties of $2,000 per car, and must offer the purchaser or lessee their choice of a refund or a comparable vehicle without charge.

As added protection, the amendment mandates that manufacturers apply for a branded lemon title from PennDOT before the car can be resold, leased or transferred in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. The title branding then remains throughout the life of the vehicle and cannot be removed. For more information on consumers’ rights under the Pennsylvania Lemon Law, including cost-free legal representation, consumers can visit Lemon Law or call 1-800-LEMON-LAW (1-800-536-6652).